CLASSIC CORNER

Classic Corner features mysteries from the past currently in re-release.

JANUARY - FEBRUARY  REVIEWS

MAN ON THE BOULEVARD
GEORGES SIMENON
Translated from the French by Eileen Ellenbogen
Penguin Classics Trade pb reprint 1/08

Maigret and the Man on the BoulevardChief Inspector Maigret of Paris, France, is called to the murder of a man in a small, dark, cul-de-sac between two buildings.  He has been stabbed in the back.  When his wife comes to the morgue to identify him, she is startled that he is wearing light brown shoes.  He always wore black; she had polished them that morning.  And he was wearing a too-garish tie.  When Maigret and his detectives begin to investigate the crime, Maigret learns that the business where the man worked had been closed for three years.  Yet he had money.  He spent his time sitting on a bench on the boulevard.

Maigret comes into contact with several of the victim’s friends:  the landlady of a rooming house, a middle-aged woman friend, a former circus acrobat, and his daughter.  In his usual style, Simenon lets the reader speculate what the seemingly simple question-and-answer sessions reveal.  One who says little or nothing may, in fact, be revealing important information.  Simenon’s deceptively simplistic writing style hooks the reader from the first.  He knows human nature and how it reveals itself, often unknowingly.  His suspense and people grab the reader.  Simenon is unbeatable.

Inspector Cadaver
Also in Penguin Classic reprint:  INSPECTOR CADAVER.  When Maigret is called to a small, very damp, town, Saint-Autin-les-Marais, to check into the odd death of a young man apparently killed by lying on a train track under the grinding wheels of a train, he is startled to see that a man known as Old Cadaver, Justin Cavre, a former policeman with whom Maigret had problems, gets off at the same small town.  As Maigret attempts to interview residents, Cavre is doing the same.

My Friend Maigret

MY FRIEND MAIGRET.  Maigret is sent to a very hot Mediterranean island to investigate the murder of a man who had boasted about his “friend” Maigret.  Maigret must take along with him Scotland Yard Inspector Pyke, who is interested in the French detective.  Maigret checks into almost the entire island population shadowed by Pyke who seems like a “serious-minded student.”  All the characters are vividly portrayed.

 - Janet Overmyer

Home Page

NOVEMBER - DECEMBER  REVIEWS


A CLUBBABLE WOMAN
REGINALD HILL
Felony & Mayhem pb 9/07
ISBN: 978-1-933397-93-1

This is a reissue of the very first Dalziel and Pascoe mystery, featuring the wonderfully mismatched pair of Yorkshire coppers who have subsequently been featured in twenty-four books. (There’s also a British TV series, now entering its 12th season, but shown minimally here in the States, drat the luck.)  Published nearly forty years ago, the two lead characters are portrayed in somewhat skin-and-bones fashion in their debut, although the pattern for their character development is well laid down. When an aging former seductress is found dead in her living room from a bash on her head, the obvious suspect is her husband, an aging amateur rugby player. But Andy Dalziel, local Detective Superintendent and ex-rugby player himself, isn’t convinced. He does think that the local rugby club and its denizens may hold the clues to the murder, and he drags Detective Sergeant Peter Pascoe along to the venue to teach him the ways of the world as they go about their sleuthing. Andy is loud, crude, devious and brilliant in his methods, and Peter uses his own highly educated and sensitive wits to assist with the case. The more people they interview, the more evident it becomes that rugby wasn’t the only game being played by the club members, and the pair ultimately resolve the crime in splendidly satisfying fashion. The dialogue is utterly remarkable, and Pascoe’s unspoken monologues are frequently revealing and often extremely funny. (I confess that I know little about rugby, and some of the game-related discussions might as well have been done in Sanskrit. But I don’t think I missed out on any crucial plot stuff due to my ignorance.)  Hill has been one of my favorite authors for years, and I’m ecstatic to know that his early works are being re-released so that I can flesh out my collection.

 - Carol Howell


DEATH OF A DUTCHMAN

MAGDALEN NABB
Soho Press Trade pb 12/07
ISBN:  978-1-56947-482-2

During an overheated July in Florence , Marshall Guarnaccia reluctantly visits the elderly woman who repeatedly calls the police with various complaints, a guise to lure them to her apartment where she can alleviate her loneliness and keep them captive with her loquaciousness. But this time, Guarnaccia finds there’s a genuine problem – the old lady’s neighbor, a Dutch jeweler, is dying.  Despite the initial impression that he had attempted suicide, careful investigation after his death reveals that Toni Goossens had been murdered. His pregnant young wife is at their home miles away in Amsterdam, his Florentine business associates have no apparent reason to harm him, and the mysterious woman who was with him just prior to his death has left no clue to her identity. The victim’s dying comment had been: “It wasn’t her.” The case isn’t even in Guarnaccia’s purview, which makes his determination to continue the investigation all the more difficult.  He is dogged in his pursuit of the killer, and his meticulous methodology includes a slow chase through the Boboli Gardens in the summer heat that is quite mesmerizing.  DEATH OF A DUTCHMAN was first published twenty-five years ago, and this reprint gave me the opportunity to meet Guarnaccia, an intriguing Italian policeman in a fascinating Italian city.  He’s extraordinarily self-effacing as well as gentle and caring, and very much a loner, forced to live away from his family who are in Southern Italy, and lacking even a work confidante with whom he can discuss his concerns. Definitely a fella worth spending a lot more time with.

 - Carol Howell

CLOSE QUARTERS
MICHAEL GILBERT
Rue Morgue Press Trade pb 5/07
ISBN: 978-1-60187-006-3 

The Dean of Melchester Cathedral is deeply distressed at the flurry of hate materials directed against elderly senior verger Appledown. He is sufficiently upset to break the customary isolationistic tranquility of the religious setting to invite his nephew to take time off from his usual job at Scotland Yard to pay a visit and take an unofficial look at what is happening. Just as young Sergeant Pollock settles in and, with the aid of a map of the Close, helpfully reprinted for the reader, identifies the residents of the locale, the unthinkable happens. Old Appledown is murdered.  With customary diplomatic tiptoeing around the local constabulary to avoid stepping on – well – toes, Pollock is joined by his superior, Chief Inspector Hazlerigg, who leads an insightful and skillful investigation. As is typical in such a small community, everyone knows everything about everyone else (or at least they think that they do) and no one can twitch a curtain without several witnesses spotting the action from behind their own hiding spots. Motives appear sparse, and opportunity even more so. By careful reconstruction of the events of the night of the murder, suspects get eliminated and the hunt narrows down to a select few. Watching the pair of hardworking coppers track down the killer is greatly entertaining and, despite the absence of deeply depicted characterizations, they are a likable and admirable pair.

This classic reprint is the first novel by Michael Gilbert, a prolific British author who won numerous prestigious awards during his lengthy career. Set in the Close of a Cathedral that is marvelously similar to that of Salisbury Cathedral, this is a cozy police procedural with classic red herrings, classic literary references, and charmingly biting, tongue-in-cheek humor. There’s even a crossword puzzle that plays a crucial role. An utterly delightful blast from the past. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.

 - Carol Howell

THE ARCHER FILES
ROSS MACDONALD 
Edited by Tom Nolan
Crippen & Landru  8/07
ISBN:  hc  978-1-932009-62-0  Trade pb: 978-1-932009-63-7

THE ARCHER FILES includes all the Lew Archer short stories featured in THE NAME IS ARCHER and LEW ARCHER, PRIVATE INVESTIGATOR plus two new stories and a section on Archer’s case notes, as told to Ross Macdonald. Normally, I don’t like short stories, but in this case this book reveals a side of private investigator Lew Archer not seen in the novels.

First, there is the introduction, which is actually a history of Archer’s early life up through the military, the police department and how, eventually, he becomes a private investigator in California. It seems his early life was dominated by  his mother and grandmother, who had hoped Lew would become a priest or do some service in a religious setting. This background helps Archer deal with all the people in his various cases as he uses a deep understanding of what makes people tick to find the resolutions to his cases.

Then, there is a section of  short stories in which we meet a young Lew Archer. In several of the cases it Archer’s understanding of what makes people do the things they do that helps him to survive the brutal nonchalance of murder that takes place on an almost daily basis. This quality also allows him to deal with drug dealers, blackmailers, thugs, and people who think they are above the law and don’t have to pay for their crimes. Following the short stories are a list of case notes that were either used in some stories, or were just basic facts of a case that Archer dealt with, but didn’t record into a story or news item. These notes show how a private investigator takes facts of the case and tries to make sense of them, especially when the facts tend to contradict each other.

THE ARCHER FILES is a must have for people who have read the Ross Macdonald novels of Lew Archer. Or, if new to the mystery reading field, this is a great introduction to a writer who wrote some of the most complex mysteries featuring this private investigator. This is a collection that fills in the gaps in Lew Archer’s compendium of cases.

 - Steven Sill

THE WIDENING STAIN
MORRIS BISHOP
Rue Morgue Press Trade pb 10/07
ISBN: 978-1-60187-008-7

Professor Coffman, a member of the psychology department at an august Ivy League university, has got it all figured out when it comes to why his colleagues couldn't possibly be guilty of a violent crime. The way he sees it, "People on the faculty as a rule know enough about psychology, including their own, to diagnose their own troubles. We work off our crimes in conversation, or in imagination, or in reading.  That's what love stories are for.  And murder stories.  Here's a motto for the faculties: read a good book and keep the commandments."   

That may be good advice, but in practice someone on the staff may have done the reading part but the individual has been more than just a little lax in keeping the commandments. The body of a French professor found in the school's library attests to the fact that someone has not only violated the "Thou shall not kill" commandment, but also apparently ignored a few others as well.

Enter Professor Francis Parry, whose sleuthing abilities rival his unfortunate penchant for creating limericks at inappropriate times. To counter the bumbling efforts of the local police detective assigned to the homicide, Parry and some of his colleagues take it upon themselves to  discover who was responsible for pushing Mademoiselle Lucie Coindreau over the edge, thus violating the inner sanctum of the Wilmerding Library.

A reprint of a mystery first published in 1942, this comic whodunit was written under the pseudonym W. Bolingbroke Johnson, the pen name adopted by Morris Bishop. A Professor of Romance Literature at Cornell, Bishop also served for awhile as the university's provost. A writer of light verse that often appeared in The New Yorker, Life  and The Saturday Evening Post, Morris had perhaps too much "fun" at the expense of his own school, thinly disguised as "the university" in this work. Fearing perhaps social repercussions at the time, using another name seemed a wise course of action. 

Reputedly, THE WIDENING STAIN was so well received it went through a number of printings when it was first issued. Thanks to Tom and Enid Schantz of Rue Morgue Press, today's readers can judge for themselves if Bishop's "japery and inside knowledge of academic life" are as amusing today as they were sixty-five years ago. 

- Bob Walch

THE DANGER WITHIN
MICHAEL GILBERT       
Rue Morgue Press Trade pb 7/07
ISBN:  978-1601870094

In 1952, Michael Gilbert gave the mystery world a locked room murder set in an Italian POW camp during World War II. The Rue Morgue Press re-release gives this crime classic a new audience and reminds all mystery fans why the Brits have a corner on the classic mystery genre.

A POW himself, Gilbert’s descriptions of camp life and routines has absolute credibility and his characters run the gamut of the Allied powers, from Gary Cooper look-alike American Air Force colonels to Royal Navy types with bushy red beards. His Axis guards are a mix of brutal fascists and war-weary Italian guards who are willing to sell almost anything for a price.

When a suspected German spy is found dead in a collapsed section of escape tunnel, none of the prisoners cry any tears. It is only when the scene is studied more closely that they begin to realize that they have a serious problem on their hands. The alleged informer, a heartily disliked Greek soldier named Cyriakos Coutoules, is found at the end of Camp 127’s longest escape tunnel, mere yards from opening a route to freedom. The tunnel entrance is concealed by a trap door that requires four strong men and pulleys to open. No one was with Coutoules after roll call the night he died and the tunnel crew saw him alive at the time the trap door was closed for the night. If his body is left where it was found, the guards will discover his absence at the next roll call, destroy the tunnel and set back escape efforts by months.

The escape committee decides to move the body to another tunnel, which has been abandoned, report the death to the guards and pretend to know nothing about the circumstances. When the fascists conclude that the death was murder rather than an accident and announce that they will execute the British officer that they believe was the murderer, the leaders of the prisoners decide that the truth has to be discovered, fast.

Enter Captain Henry “Cuckoo” Goyles, a former headmaster, master tunneller and amateur detective. Using all of the classic methodology perfected by Agatha Christie for Poirot and Miss Marple, Goyles begins asking questions, watching for reactions, and analyzing everything, pushed by the deadline of the upcoming firing squad.

A lively period piece with enough plot twists to keep even the most jaded reader guessing, THE DANGER WITHIN’s re-release will establish Michael Gilbert, a MWA Grandmaster, CWA Diamond Dagger winner and Bouchercon lifetime achievement honoree, as a must-read treasure for a new generation of fans.  HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.

 - W. J. H. Reed

THE WAY SOME PEOPLE DIE 
ROSS MACDONALD   
Vintage Crime / Black Lizard Trade pb 7/07

When Galatea “Galley” Lawrence disappears, her mother hires Lew Archer to find her. At first, he doesn’t want to take the case, as he feels that Galatea has gone off with some friends or just needed to get away for awhile. Thus, THE WAY SOME PEOPLE DIE, opens with Archer slowly getting drawn into a case that will turn dangerous.

As Archer’s investigation begins, he doesn’t see anything going wrong. However, he soon learns that Galley has fallen in with a mobster, Joe Tarantine, who might be responsible for the attempted murder of his boss, Herman Speed. It is at the hospital where Speed is taken that Galley and Joe meet. From there, things get even more dangerous as Danny Dowser, who lost a large shipment of drugs to Tarantine, tries to get Archer to retrieve the drugs for him.

Then the murders start. Archer is looking for the connections when suddenly it all becomes clear. With a resounding resolution, THE WAY SOME PEOPLE DIE, ends with everything tidied up, as the mobsters get arrested and the murders solved.

I really enjoyed rereading this vintage Ross Macdonald mystery. This author knew how to plot complex but readable mysteries. Using family as the main motive for whatever could go wrong with a child or how the past could come back to play a part in a modern murder, the author could spin a reliable and entertaining mystery.

 - Steven Sill

THE BLACK CURL
CONSTANCE and GWENYTH LITTLE
Rue Morgue Press Trade pb 6/07
ISBN: 978-1-60187-007-0

Bill Runson is not having a good week.  The head of a nameless company, whose cousin, Eliot, drinks a great deal and sponges off him, he is being faced with a number of problems.  His stepmother, Irene, and her daughter, Madeleine, appear suddenly at his house to visit.  His housekeeper, Mrs. Goodhue, disappears, and a Mrs. Reilly and her son, Joe, arrive; the former to take the housekeeper’s position.  And then odd things happen.

Joe, immediately upon turning up, faints; he does that frequently.  A portrait of Bill is no longer on the wall, although it does later turn up.  The coffee is doped.  Bill awakens to find that the curl of hair on his forehead has been cut off while he slept.  The hair oil in Bill’s bottle has been replaced with water.  But none of this matters when a murdered body is found in the bottom of the refrigerator.  And Dykes, a police detective, turns up to investigate and another body turns up.

This delightful novel, the 21st and last of the Little Sisters, shows their usual quickly made-out people, their humor, and their involved but believable solution.  They make some valid points about human relationships.  “They (women) should have an interest outside of romance, as men do.”  Bill’s comment.  Those sisters well deserve to have their works reprinted, and they should now be read by a new generation that loves light-hearted tales with ongoing suspense.  VERY HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.

 - Janet Overmyer

Home Page